Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Stila Eyeliner Set Review

Hi everyone! :)

Today I have a review on the Seeing Stars Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner Set from Sephora.  I bought this around the holidays for about $30.  They feature five subtle shimmery metallic colors.

Staying Power: I was frankly really impressed with how long they stayed on.  It stays on for about 12 hours before it slightly fades away.  It really is smudge-free and it never transferred to my lower eyelid.  Although some people complain of a waxy substance sticking to their contacts after using this liner, I never had that problem.

Texture: It is so unbelievably smooth and creamy to the point it has become a problem for me.  If I apply even a little bit of pressure, it breaks off and I end up wasting a bit of the product.  It applies best for me if you twist up the product so that it's barely above the opening (see picture below)


*all shades are of a shimmery metallic tone*


Sheer black color.  You will need to apply two or three coats to get a dark black color.


Pearly purple color.  Up close you can tell it's purple but it appears a bit brownish when you're far away.  


Subtle olive green color.  Olive green may not be the most attractive color, but this one is really gentle and quiet.  Again, the color looks a bit brownish from far away, especially after applying several coats.

Oscar Fish

Soft, light brown color.  This color is great for lining the upper lid for a light, natural pop to your eyes.


Beautiful light pearly pink color.  It's great for lining your lower lashline to highlight the inner corners.  It's not as bright and pearly as the picture when you apply it to your eyes.  

Warning: Because it is SUPER creamy, the liner breaks off really easily like warm butter.  Also, the twisting device only pushes it up.  It doesn't retract the liner. Keep that in mind before twisting the liner up several inches because you won't be able to put it back in.  

Check it out here

Have a great day everyone :)


  1. omgosh, thanks for the review, I LOVE Stila~~~! I remember that I made an order for this Stila eyeliner set but sadly the product never arrived to my mail T___T.

    thanks for your comment on my blog and keep blogging <3

    1. thank you so much :D i still have a long way to go until my blog looks as amazing as yours ㅠㅠ

  2. this set looks GORGEOUS! :O
    where have i been without them haha

    1. it really is ^^
      thanks so much for stopping by!

  3. tetra looks nice and moray too :) it is very rare to find such colors for eyeliners. thank you for sharing!

    btw, i hope can join my giveaway. here's the link: CHICNOVA GIVEAWAY~❤❤❤

    1. entered! :) it's a great giveaway ^^

  4. i love these.... adding these to my wishlist :)
    thanks for dropping by, returning your visit ...

  5. It's Angelfish that caught my attention the most.:D

  6. The color angelfish is beautiful!! I love all Stila products!

    I Follow you now by the way via bloglovin (#3)
    If you have time could you check out/ follow my blog too?

    1. following :)
      thanks for stopping by!

  7. I found your blog via Sprinkleofglitter, it's fab. Stop putting yourself down about it; you've just started out, and the quality of your posts are great...I'm following :') x Olwyn


  8. Those colors are so pretty! I love the angelfish color!


  9. thanks so much! your blog is super interesting as well! following right back :D

  10. This is such an amazing review =D I'm LOVING your blog! I'm your newest follower via bloglovin. I'd love it if you could check out my blog and follow back? Also, it'd be great if we'd be able to connect on twitter! Let me know if you add me, so that I can follow you back there too =D

    Twitter: Sensiblestylist

  11. Oh sweetie really lovely colors of eyeliner, Angelfish was one to my favorites.



  12. thanks so much :) !
    following :D
    unfortunately, i don't have a twitter, but will add you if i make one!

  13. Thanks for the detailed review! I just came across your blog and I'm your newest follower :) Would you mind checking out our blog and (if you like) following back via GFC and Bloglovin'? Looking forward to your next post! XX


  14. Oh my goodness, these looks like
    cute coloringpencils! Thanks for the
    review c: